Recent Tennessee Case Shows the Dangers of Proceeding in an Auto Accident Case Without an Attorney

Law Office of David S. Hagy, PLC

Many people involved in auto accidents often ask themselves (or their friends or relatives), do I need a lawyer? The answer to that question is not always yes, but it is far more often yes than it is no. A recent Tennessee Court of Appeals opinion illustrates some of the dangers of proceeding without a lawyer (known as proceeding pro se).

In Newman v. Allstate Insurance Company, filed on December 27, 2012, the plaintiff had filed suit after she was involved in a rear end accident, struck by another driver who then fled the scene. In such circumstances, a plaintiff will bring claims against their own insurance company, seeking to recover uninsured motorist benefits (UM). In this case, Ms. Newman sought to recover for the damage to her car and for personal injuries and lost wages. She hired an attorney and filed her case in court.

At some point in the case, Ms. Newman’s attorney sought to withdraw from representing her. While the Court of Appeals’ opinion does not specify the reason, latter events indicate that Ms. Newman was likely not willing to accept her attorney’s advice and/or had unreasonable expectations about the case. After the attorney withdrew (and perhaps before), the insurance company (Allstate) offered her the total available amount of coverage, or $30,000. Ms. Newman did not accept the offer.

In most auto accident cases, the limits of insurance coverage represent the maximum amount a plaintiff can recover. In some case, for instance, when the defendant is a large corporation or the individual has substantial assets (millions of dollars, usually, and not less), it can be possible to reject an offer of policy limits and seek to recover more by obtaining a judgment. In such a case, a plaintiff would be able to recover against the policy and the assets of the defendant. But this is extremely rare, and collecting against an individual’s assets is difficult. In a case proceeding only against UM coverage (such as Ms. Newman’s), there is absolutely no reason to reject a policy limits offer as there are no other assets to go after. In other words, what Ms. Newman apparently did lacked any rational basis. Most likely her former attorney had explained that to her.

In any event, after rejecting the offer, Ms. Newman took the case to trial and recovered only $5,000, far less than Allstate had offered. The Court of Appeals upheld that verdict, finding that her medical proof was lacking, as it appeared that her doctors could not connect her general complaints of pain to the accident. There was also evidence that she was malingering and that she did not need to miss work when she claimed. The Court of Appeals taxed the costs of the appeal to Ms. Newman.

The end result of this case is that Ms. Newman most likely will end up with little if any recovery. That is not how it should have been, had she hired an attorney and listened rationally to his advice. Having lost her attorney through withdrawal, she then proceeded to attempt to prove a difficult damages case on her own and was roundly and clearly beaten by the experienced lawyers for the insurance company. Experienced trial attorneys can assist injured clients in Tennessee in negotiating with the insurance company, and in properly preparing, filing, and litigating cases in court. Of course, as the Newman example makes clear, any assistance they provide will do no good if the client is not willing to listen to advice.

This is not to say that a client must do what an attorney tells them. In fact, quite the opposite. An attorney in an auto accident case, just like in any other case, serves the client, and seeks to provide his best judgment based on his experience. In some situations, there are several possible “right” courses of action, and the client can choose how to proceed based on their own, individual concerns. For instance, how soon might they need money? What is their tolerance for risk? Do they really want to go through the delay and stress involved in taking a case to trial? The attorney provides advice but does not dictate what the client must do. But, I suspect in Ms. Newman’s case there were not several rational alternatives, only one. She apparently did not listen to her attorney’s advice, and the poor outcome of her case is not surprising.

If you have been involved in an auto accident and want to discuss your claims with an attorney, please contact The Law Office of David S. Hagy, PLC, at (615) 975-7882.

Client Reviews

I got into a car accident a couple months ago, and David made the whole insurance process easy to understand. He took away the stress of the situation and I felt comfortable knowing I had someone like him working for my...

Jennie E.

After getting rear ended in auto accident and in back pain David handled my personal injury claim against the at fault driver's insurance company when the large, high profile law firms in town turned me down because they...

Lakin S.

After getting into my first accident, David was a huge help in getting my lawsuit figured out in a timely manner. He was able to explain to me the details of the case so I felt like I was in control of how I wanted to...

Dana P.

While visiting Nashville, my husband and I were in a pretty bad auto accident with our Uber & a tractor trailer on the highway. David was great to work with. He was quite thorough, explaining everything we would come up...

Wendy N.

We have now used David twice. He is very personable, down to earth, hard working and gets to the bottom of your situation quickly. If we are ever in a situation where hes needed, we will use him again. Highly recommend...

Megan l.

This guy, he is the one you want in your corner going against insurance companies. Super nice, and super efficient. I would recommend this guy hands down... and have!

Hastings J.

Get in Touch

Fill out the contact form or call us at (615) 975-7882 to schedule your free initial consultation.
  • Free Initial Consultation
  • 25+ Years of Experience
  • Millions Recovered

Leave Us a Message