Paula Deen Lawsuit Illustrates Dangers of a Belligerent Defense

Law Office of David S. Hagy, PLC

Most people have by now heard of the travails of celebrity chef Paula Deen, whose business empire and sponsorships crumbled this Summer following revelations from a civil lawsuit that she had used the N-word in the past and was part of other potentially offensive racially charged activities. This post is not to defend Ms. Deen nor, frankly, to argue that she deserved the enormous backlash and financial consequences that came from the revelations of apparently long ago conduct. Rather, the question is “Why?”

The lawsuit in question arose when a white employee of one of Ms. Deen’s restaurants sued her for discrimination, alleging sexual discrimination and a racially inhospitable work environment. At some point during the litigation, the attorneys for the plaintiff scheduled and took the deposition of Ms. Deen, during which numerous questions were asked about the racial allegations, Ms. Deen’s use of the N-word, etc. It was that deposition, and specifically the public release of the deposition testimony (by the attorneys for the plaintiff?), that led to the media firestorm and the destruction of Ms. Deen’s empire and career. But, again, “Why?”

This week, the Court overseeing the lawsuit against Ms. Deen, not surprisingly, dismissed the claims arising from racial discrimination. According to media reports, the plaintiff’s claims were dismissed because as a white woman she didn’t have standing to seek damages for discrimination against non-whites. That comes as no surprise to me and I doubt it does to any lawyer practicing in employment discrimination. If these claims had been eliminated earlier in the lawsuit, the deposition questions relating to race would have been objectionable and likely the attorneys could have prevented Ms. Deen from having to answer such questions. The whole firestorm could have been avoided, perhaps. But it didn’t need to come to that.

Ms. Deen had been an enormously successful TV personality for years, with huge ratings on television along with numerous cookbooks, appearances, all in addition to several restaurants which she owned or was associated with. The real question to me, is why on Earth did Ms. Deen (or her attorneys) stubbornly battle a racially charged lawsuit to the point where evidence was uncovered that destroyed her career. The lawsuit could have likely been bought off for pennies — and, given the revelations, that wouldn’t have been buying off a frivolous lawsuit but actually paying a reasonable settlement for a meritorious one. But even if it were buying off a frivolous lawsuit (the racial allegations were dismissed), so what? An individual or business with Ms. Deen’s resources has far too much at stake to play such a high stakes game.

There are numerous potential costs to any litigation matter — a potential adverse judgment is only one such cost. There are also costs of defense (attorney’s fees), costs of business disruption, emotional toll, and (as here) negative publicity. Attorneys must discuss all potential costs of a lawsuit with their clients, whether they are defendants or plaintiffs, and make sure that the client understands and makes an informed choice about the strategy to pursue in the litigation. In Paula Deen’s case, it seems to me that either Ms. Deen’s lawyers, or Ms. Deen herself, ignored the tangential costs and risks associated with litigation to her enormous detriment.

Client Reviews

I got into a car accident a couple months ago, and David made the whole insurance process easy to understand. He took away the stress of the situation and I felt comfortable knowing I had someone like him working for my...

Jennie E.

After getting rear ended in auto accident and in back pain David handled my personal injury claim against the at fault driver's insurance company when the large, high profile law firms in town turned me down because they...

Lakin S.

After getting into my first accident, David was a huge help in getting my lawsuit figured out in a timely manner. He was able to explain to me the details of the case so I felt like I was in control of how I wanted to...

Dana P.

While visiting Nashville, my husband and I were in a pretty bad auto accident with our Uber & a tractor trailer on the highway. David was great to work with. He was quite thorough, explaining everything we would come up...

Wendy N.

We have now used David twice. He is very personable, down to earth, hard working and gets to the bottom of your situation quickly. If we are ever in a situation where hes needed, we will use him again. Highly recommend...

Megan l.

This guy, he is the one you want in your corner going against insurance companies. Super nice, and super efficient. I would recommend this guy hands down... and have!

Hastings J.

Get in Touch

Fill out the contact form or call us at (615) 975-7882 to schedule your free initial consultation.
  • Free Initial Consultation
  • 25+ Years of Experience
  • Millions Recovered

Leave Us a Message